Showing posts with label Privatization. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Privatization. Show all posts
Monday, October 4, 2010
Privatization.
Of course the market always works, and benefits everyone, while the government is evil and must be stopped.
Labels:
Privatization
Tuesday, July 13, 2010
Public-private parternships.
That catchphrase has been tossed around more than a few times by our City Council and City Manager. Hopefully they'll read this article and start to think a little more critically about this issue.
After all, didn't we just extricate the City from a public-private partnership with National Grid?
After all, didn't we just extricate the City from a public-private partnership with National Grid?
Labels:
Privatization,
Worcester
Wednesday, January 13, 2010
"Let business do what it does best." - Mike O'Brien
In this article regarding snow removal, the final paragraph stood out, which proves that you always have to read every article through until the last word.
"Meanwhile, the city is facing a potential $600,000 liability because its budget-savings plan to purchase the streetlight system from National Grid has been delayed because of complex negotiations. This year’s municipal budget had assumed a savings of $1.2 million generated by the acquisition of the streetlight network."There's been a big push by Mike O'Brien to privatize the City's parking assets. The Research Bureau wants to privatize pretty much everything. Why would the City want to buy our streetlight system if private business is the most efficient way to deliver City services?
Labels:
Economy,
Parking,
Privatization,
Worcester
Thursday, December 10, 2009
Privatize this, Part 3!
Here's a quote from U.S.PIRG's website regarding PPPs and how the public needs to safeguard themselves:
"The city should ensure that any future privatization deals adhere to the following principles:
• The public should retain control over decisions that affect the broader public interest.
• The public must receive full value so future revenues are not sold off at a discount.
• No deal should last longer than 30 years because of uncertainty over future conditions, because the risks of a bad deal grow exponentially over time, and because long contracts transfer unnecessary control to the concessionaire.
• Contracts should require state-of-the-art maintenance and safety standards instead of statewide minimums.
• There must be complete transparency to ensure proper vetting of privatization proposals.
• There must be full accountability in which the elected legislative body must approve both the authority to negotiate a deal and any terms of a final deal.
In addition, the city should adopt procedural safeguards for future privatization proposals that include the following:
• A minimum waiting period of 30 days between publication of the final terms of a privatization agreement and a vote (45 days for privatization of assets or services valued at more than $50 million).
• Competitive, transparent bidding for all professional services provided during the privatization process and for the privatization contract itself.
• Disqualification of city councilors from voting on privatization proposals when they have received campaign contributions from companies that bid on a given asset or performed professional services related to privatization. The Mayor’s office should similarly reject contributions from such companies and publicize contributions received for a defined period prior to the decision to consider privatizing an asset.
• Thorough, independent analysis of the valuation of assets proposed for concession agreements along with a comparison of privatization with other alternatives (including the option of bonding against future revenues with the same schedule of user fee increases without a private lease or transfer of ownership).
• Prompt public disclosure of all documents related to privatization bids.
• Clear directions for how proceeds from the sale will be allocated, along with the development of tools to enable the public to track spending of proceeds from privatization over time. These tracking tools should be integrated into a city wide budget transparency Web site that would enable citizens to have “one-stop” access to all city expenditures.
• Timely public disclosure of all documents relevant to a privatization proposal, including posting of such documents on a publicly accessible Web site.
Finally, to bolster confidence, trust, and transparency in government, Chicago should follow the example of a growing number of cities and states that provide detailed and up-todate searchable information about government contracting and expenditures on-line.
Specifically, the city should create a one-stop, comprehensive, on-line database that would enable citizens to obtain information on contracts, the current status of city accounts, special tax breaks, fee services accrued, economic development subsidies and city budgets. The Web site should provide summary information and enable residents to drill down to detailed information on city payments, including the city’s check register. The Web site should also retain previous years’ data for comparison."
I hope our City Council, City Manager, and local newspapers keep this in mind as this debate progresses. I know I will.
"The city should ensure that any future privatization deals adhere to the following principles:
• The public should retain control over decisions that affect the broader public interest.
• The public must receive full value so future revenues are not sold off at a discount.
• No deal should last longer than 30 years because of uncertainty over future conditions, because the risks of a bad deal grow exponentially over time, and because long contracts transfer unnecessary control to the concessionaire.
• Contracts should require state-of-the-art maintenance and safety standards instead of statewide minimums.
• There must be complete transparency to ensure proper vetting of privatization proposals.
• There must be full accountability in which the elected legislative body must approve both the authority to negotiate a deal and any terms of a final deal.
In addition, the city should adopt procedural safeguards for future privatization proposals that include the following:
• A minimum waiting period of 30 days between publication of the final terms of a privatization agreement and a vote (45 days for privatization of assets or services valued at more than $50 million).
• Competitive, transparent bidding for all professional services provided during the privatization process and for the privatization contract itself.
• Disqualification of city councilors from voting on privatization proposals when they have received campaign contributions from companies that bid on a given asset or performed professional services related to privatization. The Mayor’s office should similarly reject contributions from such companies and publicize contributions received for a defined period prior to the decision to consider privatizing an asset.
• Thorough, independent analysis of the valuation of assets proposed for concession agreements along with a comparison of privatization with other alternatives (including the option of bonding against future revenues with the same schedule of user fee increases without a private lease or transfer of ownership).
• Prompt public disclosure of all documents related to privatization bids.
• Clear directions for how proceeds from the sale will be allocated, along with the development of tools to enable the public to track spending of proceeds from privatization over time. These tracking tools should be integrated into a city wide budget transparency Web site that would enable citizens to have “one-stop” access to all city expenditures.
• Timely public disclosure of all documents relevant to a privatization proposal, including posting of such documents on a publicly accessible Web site.
Finally, to bolster confidence, trust, and transparency in government, Chicago should follow the example of a growing number of cities and states that provide detailed and up-todate searchable information about government contracting and expenditures on-line.
Specifically, the city should create a one-stop, comprehensive, on-line database that would enable citizens to obtain information on contracts, the current status of city accounts, special tax breaks, fee services accrued, economic development subsidies and city budgets. The Web site should provide summary information and enable residents to drill down to detailed information on city payments, including the city’s check register. The Web site should also retain previous years’ data for comparison."
I hope our City Council, City Manager, and local newspapers keep this in mind as this debate progresses. I know I will.
Labels:
Economy,
local politics,
Parking,
Privatization,
Worcester
Privatize this, Part 2!
It's been 18 days since I posted this, and 21 since Mike O'Brien's speech. (And more than a years since he first proposed the idea.) Nicole has blogged about it twice, including emails to city officials.
I feel like Keith Olberman's closing speech throughout the Bush Administration.
Today, Worcester Magazine's Jeremy Shulkin broached the subject of selling the City's parking resources. I'm tired, cranky and don't really want to write about this, but here goes the quick quick version until I have more time and energy.
-Mr. Shulkin mentions that Harrisburg, PA had an offer for $215 million and rejected the deal. He also mentions discontent in Washington D.C. and Chicago regarding ticketing policies and high prices. Why doesn't he go into detail about these cities? Is it the limitation of the print media? Or is it because this seems to be a largely pro-privatization piece?
-Mr. Shulkin relies extensively on Rick Norment, the Executive Director of the National Council for Public-Private Partnerships to discuss the benefits and drawbacks of privatization.
-The NCPPP is an organization that relies on the existence of privatization (or their euphemism of Pubic-Private Partnerships). Where is the voice from the other side? How can Mr. Norment be the only expert quoted in this article?
Here's a few reasons why people mistrust privatization.
Eight links, minimal effort, three searches on Google that took nanoseconds and then some reading.
I feel like Keith Olberman's closing speech throughout the Bush Administration.
Today, Worcester Magazine's Jeremy Shulkin broached the subject of selling the City's parking resources. I'm tired, cranky and don't really want to write about this, but here goes the quick quick version until I have more time and energy.
-Mr. Shulkin mentions that Harrisburg, PA had an offer for $215 million and rejected the deal. He also mentions discontent in Washington D.C. and Chicago regarding ticketing policies and high prices. Why doesn't he go into detail about these cities? Is it the limitation of the print media? Or is it because this seems to be a largely pro-privatization piece?
-Mr. Shulkin relies extensively on Rick Norment, the Executive Director of the National Council for Public-Private Partnerships to discuss the benefits and drawbacks of privatization.
-The NCPPP is an organization that relies on the existence of privatization (or their euphemism of Pubic-Private Partnerships). Where is the voice from the other side? How can Mr. Norment be the only expert quoted in this article?
Here's a few reasons why people mistrust privatization.
Eight links, minimal effort, three searches on Google that took nanoseconds and then some reading.
Labels:
Economy,
local politics,
Parking,
Privatization,
Worcester
Sunday, November 22, 2009
Privatize This!
I was at Worcester Local First's Networking Party at Commerce Bank on Main Street. The City Manager spoke and addressed his ten points of interest for the business community.
The point that caught my attention was his future goal of privatizing some city services, namely the garages and parking meters. He hopes to sell the managing rights (and future profits) in exchange for a one time fee to help the city through our current fiscal crisis.
I know we're facing a huge budget shortfall for the next few years, but let's not start privatizing services. The track record for privatization is terrible.
Worcester drivers will end up paying more for parking for however many years the deal is in effect while the city gets a one time fee. Will it be enough?
Where was the T&G with this news nugget? "Your search for parking privatization resulted in 0 articles."
The point that caught my attention was his future goal of privatizing some city services, namely the garages and parking meters. He hopes to sell the managing rights (and future profits) in exchange for a one time fee to help the city through our current fiscal crisis.
I know we're facing a huge budget shortfall for the next few years, but let's not start privatizing services. The track record for privatization is terrible.
Worcester drivers will end up paying more for parking for however many years the deal is in effect while the city gets a one time fee. Will it be enough?
Where was the T&G with this news nugget? "Your search for parking privatization resulted in 0 articles."
Labels:
Economy,
local politics,
Parking,
Privatization,
Worcester
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
